Female relationship has been a very fragile place in my life for … well, always. Because of this I did not trust my instincts near enough. It wasn’t until 27 or 28 that I first started realizing how some of my friendships give insight into my sense of worth.
From a young age, I developed a core belief that said you should never walk away from relationships. That to do so is selfish and immature. And there is some truth here because it certainly is easier and immature to throw away something messy and start over with someone new- a clean slate- rather than being vulnerable, risking more hurt or disappointment by being in a relationship with imperfect people. It’s easier to wash our hands and walk away, to look for the next best thing that makes us feel good than to keep plugging away with the one who has wounded you as well loved you. But it also robs us of depth and intimacy. It robs us of opportunities to see ourselves and the other in a new way. It robs us of the opportunity to forgive, to see our need for forgiveness and seek it. It robs us of joy in restored relationship.
I also developed a core belief that said if something was wrong in the relationship and the other person said or thought it was me than it must be.
About two years ago, I noticed a couple of patterns in my life:
1.) Because I have made my life here, without my family, I hoped and believed I had built and grown into a family system of friends. Two years ago, I finally realized they had their own sisters who were their actual family. It trumped the friendship. Blood is thicker than water. And that's okay. I just needed to realize it.
2.) If I stopped working tirelessly toward some of the friendships I have – in other words, if I stopped attending to the person’s needs and making them feel special and important and listened to, the friendships basically fell apart. More times than not, I would go through a small grieving at the loss of the friendship and what I thought it was but now realized it wasn’t. That’s probably too simple but anyway… I would sometimes get angry and have emotional conversations with them in my bathroom mirror. I would talk it out with Jason for weeks. Then, I would eventually let it go. I released the person from my expectations of them and my own needs in the friendship. I would protect my heart by backing away slowly, very slowly until there was enough room that I no longer felt vulnerable in my needs and how they were not meeting them or seeming to notice. I backed away without working through the process with the other. Most of the time, I was content to receive them on the terms they came (which were also my terms) after my little grieving process. I accepted the friendship for what it was. I think I also realized that no matter how much legwork I put in, the result would always be the same. At this point, they usually started noticing that I was not giving them all they were used to. This is when they started noticing and becoming upset with me. They started feeling their needs going unmet and resented me. And then a vicious cycle began of me feeling obligated to engage on their terms, them feeling more happy because I was doing so and me feeling confused. I would hear the old tape in my head telling me that I was selfish and immature if I did not re-engage in ways they wanted. Their cold shoulder would trigger all of my childhood stuff to start working hard again to regain their love and approval. And on it would go.
Not a nice cycle.
These are beloved people I’m talking about. They are beautiful people and they are loving and witty and fun and selfish and they are wounded and they have their own stuff they don’t even see. Just like me. I love them and they love me. But they are also human. They aren’t perfect. Neither am I. The relationships won’t be perfect. I am okay with this now, these imperfect flawed relationships where feelings sometimes get hurt and expectations are in the wrong place.
But what is the point where I place my God-breathed worth and my heart above what other people want from me?
I live my life "out loud" in some ways. I value authenticity and being real pretty much more than anything. People (me too!) tend to like this in others and in me. Sometimes people take advantage of this without sharing their own. Yet I continue to try. Am I foolish? I’ve been wondering lately. I’m not sure how to sort it out.
I have ever only walked away from 2 friendships when the person wanted something from me.
The first one was easy. My brother had just died and a girlhood friend (early teen years), who in hindsight I can see kept me as a secret friend from all of her “cool friends” because I was somewhat of an embarrassment wrote me a sympathy card. In the card she mentioned how we had really drifted over the years and she would like to be close to my family again. If I stand outside the moment as a mature 31 year old woman, I can see this as an honest expression of her compassion and longing. I can also see it as I did then as an insensitive effort to gain access to a front and centre tragedy. To be in the know. It’s this using me to be in the know that bothered me most.
The second one was about six or seven years ago. It was heart-breaking and messy with a woman who had befriended and been a support to me throughout my teen years. It came to light that she had done something horrific toward a child. I was asked by the child – now teen – to be a part of the process. I was ill for days. How could this woman I knew and loved do something so hideous? But I also knew the girl and knew she wasn’t lying. I flew to Kansas City to talk with my friend. To confront her with this violation of a vulnerable one and hear where her heart was. My heartsick self was a wreck. When I met with her, she did not deny it. She minimized it. She brushed it under the rug. As she made excuse after excuse throughout the conversation, I felt my heart fall. So I asked her, would she commit to taking steps to avoid putting other vulnerable girls at risk? The short answer was NO. She wanted to continue to live without consequences, without safeguards – real safeguards. So with much grief in my heart I told her that if she would not make a choice toward wellness for herself and safety for other young girls, I would not continue to participate in friendship with her. She chose. The friendship ended. I have no regrets about that situation. I will not be a part of unrepentant evil.
Those two – those were simple in their own ways. They were hard too because I knew those people saw those rejections as my fault rather than their own behavior resulting in loss of friendship
.
There is a tension here for me. As a Christian I am called to lay my life down, to put others before myself. I am also instructed to guard my heart – the wellspring of my life. Some days the way this should look is clear and sometimes its murky. God has given me an immense gift in the tenderness, empathy, compassion, discernment, vulnerability of my own heart. I am responsible to care for it in a way that honors what He has given me.
Over the years, I have fought for relationships. It’s not hard when things are smooth sailing. But in the muck and misunderstandings, I have fought for relationships that seem to be going down the tubes. I fight because I value people that have roots in my past and mine in theirs. I think they are worth working out. I believe it makes the friendships stronger, deeper. I fight because of those distorted core beliefs I learned as a kid. I fight because they are my people and I love them. I fight because I’m scared of being lonely. I fight because I fiercely believe in a faith-life that loves – even when it costs me something. I fight because I have known the power of restoration in broken friendships. I fight for so many reasons.
I’m kind of tired of fighting (I’m kind of tired in general these days but still…). J
Today, I want to choose my own heart. My own needs. I want to let myself rest and be. I want to see if the friendships matter as much to them as they have to me. I don’t know if this is right or wrong or if there is even a right or wrong in this. Still I’m wondering …
Will they fight? Will they blame me? Will they put themselves in my shoes? Will we fight to keep our hearts open toward one another? Will we allow each other to be human? Or will we go on pretending nothing is wrong and everything is normal when the emotional current that runs underneath the niceties is deep and charged.
I am reluctant. I want to jump into my old way. The only way I really know. The way that makes peace. The way that denies my own needs and hurts for the sake of friendship equilibrium. When is it a matter of taking my ball and playing somewhere else (petty and immature and guarded) and when is it okay to simply acknowledge it’s not my turn to fight?
What am I afraid of? That they will simply take their ball and play somewhere else? Maybe.
But I think it is more than this. After writing this post and leaving it for an hour, I realized why this issue has been so unsettling and painful for me of late. It is really the question of my whole life. I’ve been asking this question before I even knew it.
Will you love me even if I am not who you want me to be or who you think I should be?
Will you love me even when I don’t please you?
Will you love me, stay committed to me and to our relationship, when who I am is rubbing wrong with who you are?
Will you love both of us enough to be honest and to receive my honesty?
This, I think, is real love.
Maybe I can only attend to what is in my heart - what I am doing.
Whether I am being honest with myself, for myself and for them.
Whether I am being honest with them, for them and for myself.
Whether my heart is guarded or open toward them.
I want to be patient and grounded. Not scurrying and afraid. I want to own what is mine and leave what isn't. I want to be courageous in vulnerability. I’ve had some opportunities to practice it lately. It’s H.A.R.D. It’s raw. It’s exciting. It is liberating. It’s also messy. Maybe it’s the perfect time to read the book that has been on my reading list for a bit. It's written by Brene Brown. She is an unpretentious vulnerability and shame guru. I am encouraged that there are people so much further down this journey of an authentic life.
I just checked my local Chapters. It’s in store. Getting my coat on.









